Post by @jack

I hate to admit this, but I kind of miss Lightroom Classic. It was nice having a very good RAW processor and capable catalog with a large ecosystem and all of my photos in one big library. I've spent so much time trying to concoct a non-Adobe workflow that I've forgotten why I bother. :)

Replying to @jack
shom
@shom @gts.shom.dev

@jack Lightroom Classic was great. I've essentially the same workflow in Darktable now managing import, catalog, metadata, edit, and export. Except I write everything to a xmp sidecar file. I used to do portrait images panorama stitching which I don't shoot anymore but that's the one thing I don't think I could do easily.
What are you using these days?

Replying to @shom@gts.shom.dev

@shom@gts.shom.dev I spent weeks getting the hang of Darktable. It's capable and powerful, but while it can do all of those things, I don't find it to be at all pleasant.

I've recently been trying RapidRAW, which is evolving fast, and is much more Lightroom-like. Simpler than Darktable, but nicer to use, imo. That said, it's no LrC either. Mostly I've fallen back to Capture One on my Mac. Better RAW processing, but crappy cataloging and they really focus on pro studios.

If you can stomach vibe-coded projects, there are a bunch of them popping up. Who knows what we'll end up with?!

Replying to @jack
shom
@shom @gts.shom.dev

@jack yes Darktable can be cumbersome as a new user. I recently reinstalled and they seem to be improving the experience with a nice setup wizard but even that unfortunately needs some knowledge to answer properly. Since I've already made the time investment it works for me but it is a learning curve for sure and before I learned some of it. It forced me to simply my process which was something that was a compromise at the time but it helped me just simplify altogether which was a nice benefit (not suggesting anyone else should do that).
I'm not into the vibe coded apps but the wholesale reverse/re-engineering is an interesting trend, we'll see where things land. There's a big possibility that proprietary software ends up fully opaque and remote (browser window which is basically a remote VM) instead of local. Weird times! Nostalgic for the Lightroom Classic days for sure.

Replying to @shom@gts.shom.dev

@shom@gts.shom.dev I did download that LightCraft Lrc clone. It looks like LrC, but it's terrible once you try doing anything. You're right, it's interesting though.

Replying to @jack
Jackie Plage
@jac @404brain.boo

@jack@social.baty.net I hate Adobe with a passion, but I've yet to find a good alternative to Lightroom Classic. It sucks, feel like I'm being held hostage (and also have to keep a Windows install hanging around because of it).

Replying to @jac@404brain.boo

@jac@404brain.boo Yeah, they kind of get ya stuck, which sucks. I'm ambivalent about Adobe itself, other than force-feeding me the Creative Cloud stuff. And as much as we all hate subscriptions, the Lightroom package is still a decent deal at around $11/month, imo.

Replying to @jack
Jackie Plage
@jac @404brain.boo

@jack@social.baty.net I'd agree with that, if not for the fact that they lock you in for 12 months. I often can't afford that monthly fee, and I know I'm not alone in that.

Replying to @jac@404brain.boo

@jac@404brain.boo Right, the deal looks a lot worse when paying monthly.

Replying to @jack
Cliff538
@Cliff538 @thecanadian.social

@jack I'm still entrenched in LR Classic. I've used it for so long; it feels like home. I've tried ON1 and DxO, but nothing clicks for me.

Replying to @jack
Tom Northenscold
@tomnorthfilm @mastoart.social

@jack I miss Aperture. I’m on Lr now (not LrC). If Apple comes out with an Aperture replacement I’d have to give it a look. I’d be hard-pressed to give up the masking tools in Lr though if the ones in Apple’s offering weren’t powerful enough. My biggest irritation with Lr is that it has no print capability.

@tomnorthfilm@mastoart.social Aperture was great, I miss it too. Ever since getting the Epson printer, I use Epson Print Layout for printing, so I wouldn't miss it. Besides I find the LrC print module to be inscrutable.

Replying to @jack
Tom Northenscold
@tomnorthfilm @mastoart.social

@jack I should probably use EPL. I’m just lazy I guess.